
Columbine is very In Cold Blood, by which I mean, gay author who shows far more sympathy towards the emotional killer (Dylan/Perry) over the cruel calculating one (Eric/Dick). It debunks a lot of theories, retraces everything, and imagines complex scenes based on scrupulous evidence (stomach residue leads the author to paint a last meal of potato skins).

The Book Thief has incredibly imaginative narrative (especially for a YA) and beautiful descriptions of everything, and has a more accessible, realistic, yet still vaguely hopeful "I believe that people are essentially good inside" ending. After reading it I felt pretty good about most people and the future of YA and Holocaust-lit genres. After (and during) reading Columbine I felt like my soul was being clubbed. It made me really depressed and never want to make jokes about anything again - tragedies or even breakfast - lest it offend someone or a parent of someone who was somehow involved. I think of the two, I only recommend The Book Thief.
No comments:
Post a Comment